Wobbling Galaxies: Evidence of Dark Matter Interactions?

Title: A detection of wobbling Brightest Cluster Galaxies within massive galaxy clusters

Authors: David Harvey, F. Courbin, J. P. Kneib, Ian G. McCarthy

First Author’s Institution: École Polytechnique Fédérale de Lausanne, Switzerland

Status: Submitted to the Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, Open Access

The identity of the phantom dark matter particle that dominates the Universe around us remains elusive. Scientists have searched for signs of dark matter in deep mines, designed to keep out all but the weakly interacting dark matter particle (e.g. the LUX experiment). They have searched at the Large Hadron Collider for signs of dark matter particles created in energetic collisions (check out this Particlebite). However, these methods of detecting or creating dark matter have yet to reveal the hidden identity of these ghostly particles, leaving us with the original dark matter laboratory – the astrophysical universe – as the best place to search for clues to the particle nature of dark matter.

Clouds (or “halos”) of dark matter surround the bright astrophysical objects that we can actually observe, and interact through gravity to influence these systems. (Gravity is the only force that we know affects dark matter.) Therefore, although dark matter has passed straight through our detectors and remained invisible, we can look at stars and galaxies and infer how they have been gravitationally affected by the dark particles.

So far, astrophysical observations have taught us that dark matter is not relativistic (it’s “cold”),  it’s not electrically charged (or it would interact with photons through the electromagnetic force and we would be able to see it!), and it can’t have more than very rare interactions with normal matter through any force but gravity.

However, there are many things we still don’t know about dark matter particles (in addition to the big one – what are they?), including the question addressed in today’s paper – how do dark matter particles interact with each other? Do they pass through each other like they have passed through our detectors? Or can they bump into and scatter off of each other?

Fig. 1. An image of galaxy cluster Abel 611 taken with the Large Binocular Telescope in Arizona. The BCG is visible at the center of the image. (Source: Romano, et al., 2010)

David Harvey and his coauthors use simulations and observations of galaxy clusters to study possible self-interactions between dark matter particles. In particular, they consider how the central galaxy of a galaxy cluster (referred to as the Brightest Cluster Galaxy or BCG, Fig. 1), would behave if the surrounding dark matter particles did not quietly pass by each other, but instead bounced off of each other transferring energy and momentum, like colliding billiard balls.


Dark matter collisions in the halos around galaxy clusters boost the angular momentum of the particles that have settled near the center of the halo in a high density peak, enlarging their orbits and spreading them out to form a lower density central “core.” (Fig. 2) Gravity causes the BCG to settle into the region of the dark matter halo with the highest density. In peaked halos this is a small area at the center of the dark matter halo, but in cored halos the maximum central density plateaus and is spread over a larger region, allowing the BCG to move around without being trapped in a density peak at the center of the halo. In particular, after collisions between clusters the disrupted BCG will be left “wobbling” back and forth if a core has in fact been created by dark matter self-interactions, whereas a BCG located in a density peak will settle down much more quickly.

Fig. 2. Density of peaked and cored dark matter halos as a function of radius. In the peaky halo (solid line) the density continues to increase at smaller radii, leading to a small centralized region of peak density. In the cored halo (dashed line) the density levels out at smaller radii, producing a larger region of maximum density around which a BCG is free to wobble. (Source: Popolo, 2008)

Today’s paper first uses simulations to place a limit on the BCG wobble allowed by non-interacting, peaked dark matter halos. They find a limit of the wobble amplitude of about 1/10 the size of the BCG. This means that observed galaxy cluster BCGs should not be offset from the center of the dark matter halo by more than this distance. (The center of the dark matter halo is determined using gravitational lensing.) However, when they examine the wobble in ten clusters observed by the Hubble Space Telescope they find an amplitude that is more than 5 times larger than expected. They also find that, according to this data, there is a 0.3% chance that these BCGs have zero wobble. (Fig. 3)

Fig. 3. A comparison between the BCG offsets of simulated and observed galaxy clusters. Upper panel: Simulated galaxy clusters have a very high probability of BCG offsets near 0 kpc. Lower panel: Observed galaxy clusters have significant probability of BCG offsets ranging from 0 to almost 20 kpc. This conflict could be explained by dark matter scattering. (Source: Fig. 4 from the paper.)

This is an awesome result that could lead to new insight into the nature of dark matter. However, it is important to keep in mind that simulations and observations both contain significant sources of uncertainty. Just as the quality of observations is limited by the technological constraints of telescopes and cameras, the quality of simulations is limited by the technological constraints of the computers on which they are performed. In particular, the complex, densely-packed inner regions of galaxy clusters that are relevant to this study require huge amounts of computational power and simulations inevitably include approximations and uncertainty. That being said, future work using more accurate simulations and a larger number of higher quality observations will provide exciting insight into whether there is in fact strong evidence for cores in galaxy clusters and whether these cores are formed by normal galaxy physics or by exotic dark matter self-interactions.

About Nora Shipp

I am a 2nd year grad student at the University of Chicago. I work on combining simulations and observations to learn about the Milky Way and dark matter.

Leave a Reply