A (Non?)-Magnetic White Dwarf Binary

Title: Magnetically gated accretion in an accreting ‘non-magnetic’ white dwarf

Authors: S. Scaringi, T.J. Macarone, C. D’Angelo, C. Knigge, and P.J. Groot

First Author’s Institution: University of Canterbury, Christchurch, New Zealand

Status: Accepted to Nature, open access

Figure 1: Artist’s impression of an intermediate polar — a white dwarf with an accretion disc and a strong magnetic field. The magnetic field disrupts the inner edge of the accretion disc. Source: Casey Reed / NASA

It’s a common joke among astronomers that the question, “Have you considered magnetic fields?” is always a stumper at conferences. Magnetic fields are complicated and often behave counter-intuitively. When people need to consider magnetic fields, it’s nice to be able to make simplifying assumptions: for instance, that a system is either “magnetic” or it’s “non-magnetic”. In reality, the situation can be messier. We explore an example in today’s paper.

Accretion Discs and Magnetic Fields

We’re going to be talking about how magnetic fields interact with a common astronomical phenomenon called accretion. This is when an object is trying to pull some matter onto itself (trying to “accrete” it). Because the matter has some angular momentum it cannot fall directly onto the object — instead it orbits the object and slowly spirals inwards. This inspiralling material forms an “accretion disc” around the object. Where the material falls onto the object’s surface it becomes superheated, and in many cases the accretion disc can be brighter than the central object itself. Accretion discs are seen around white dwarfs, neutron stars, stellar-mass black holes, and supermassive black holes. Today’s paper is about an example of the white dwarf case: a binary system in which a white dwarf is pulling gas from the atmosphere of a main sequence star.

Accretion discs are one of those situations where the “magnetic / non-magnetic” assumption is made. In systems with significant magnetic fields, the magnetic field breaks up the inner edge of the accretion disc — these systems are known as polars or intermediate polars (see Figure 1 for an artist’s impression). Systems where the magnetic fields are weak or non-existent are known as “non-magnetic” systems, in which the accretion disc extends right down to the surface of the white dwarf.

The Accreting Binary MV Lyr

Today’s paper is about a system called MV Lyr, which until now fell squarely into the non-magnetic category. The system was in the original field of view of the Kepler satellite, which measured changes to its brightness over the course of around four years.

Like many accretion disc systems, MV Lyr is rather messy and shows variability on all kinds of timescales (see Figure 2). This variability has several different mechanisms, but most of it is driven by changes in the rate at which the white dwarf is accreting: when the accretion rate is high, the system is bright.

Figure 2: Top: Variability of MV Lyr over several decades, showing a lot of long-term variability. The red highlighted stretch shows the 4-year stretch of the Kepler observations. Middle: A zoom-in on the lowest-magnitude stretch of the Kepler data. Bottom: Another zoom-in on the lowest-amplitude portion of the middle panel. During this low-amplitude stretch, MV Lyr shows half-hour bursts of brightness recurring roughly once every two hours. Source: Figure 1 in today’s paper.

The authors of today’s paper were particularly interested in a 20-day period of MV Lyr’s lightcurve in which the system was at its faintest. During this period the system showed strange pulses in brightness: it would get significantly brighter for about half an hour every two hours. In some cases the system would grow 6x brighter than its baseline, only to fade again half an hour later. These peculiar flashes are hard to explain as pulsations of one of the stars, or to associate with the period on which either star spins on its axis. The authors concluded that these flashes, like the longer-term variability of the system, must be driven by changes in the accretion rate of the system.

There’s one mechanism which might explain changes in the accretion rate on such a short timescale, and I’m afraid it involves magnetic fields. The mechanism is known as “magnetic gating”, and previous papers have suggested it might be at play in certain neutron star binaries and some systems with newly-formed stars. The theory runs that if the accretion rate is low, even a very weak magnetic field will disrupt the inner edge of an accretion disc. This effectively cuts off the flow of matter onto the white dwarf. That matter instead builds up in the disc, increasing its density and pressure. Eventually the pressure pushing on material at the inner edge of the disc becomes strong enough that the material can break through the magnetic field, and accretion onto the white dwarf starts again. This burst of accretion only lasts until the built-up material in the disc has been drained away, after which we see another halt in the accretion rate.

Figure 3: An illustration of the magnetic gating mechanism. In the left panel, the magnetic field disrupts the inner edge of the accretion disc, preventing matter from falling onto the white dwarf. In the right panel, once enough matter has built up in the accretion disc, the innermost matter can push through the magnetic field and accrete onto the white dwarf. Beyond a certain point the matter must follow the magnetic field lines rather than remaining as a disc. Source: Figure 3 in today’s paper.

The interesting thing about MV Lyr, as today’s paper shows, is that it doesn’t show this behaviour most of the time. When its accretion rate is high, it completely overpowers the magnetic field and the system acts as though it has no magnetic field. Only during the rare periods when the accretion rate is at its lowest does the magnetic field reveal itself. MV Lyr is one of those systems that doesn’t fit neatly into simple classification systems, and it’s just one more example of the ways magnetic fields make things more complicated.

About Matthew Green

I am a PhD student at the University of Warwick. I work with white dwarf binary systems, and in particular with AM CVn-type binaries. In my spare time I enjoy writing of all kinds, as well as playing music, board games and rock climbing. For more things written by me, take a look at my website.


  1. Una binaria de enana blanca (¿magnética?) | Astrobites en español - […] original: A (Non?)-Magnetic White Dwarf Binary, por Matthew […]

Leave a Reply