How do black holes affect the galaxy? The answer is (probably) blowin’ in the wind!

Title: AGN-driven outflows in clumpy media: multiphase structure and scaling relations

Authors:  Samuel Ruthven Ward, Tiago Costa, Chris M. Harrison, Vincenzo Mainieri

First Author’s Institution: School of Mathematics, Statistics and Physics, Newcastle University, Newcastle upon Tyne, NE1 7RU, UK

Status:  Accepted for publication in MNRAS [open access]

At the center of nearly every massive galaxy lies an energetic powerhouse, commonly called a supermassive black hole (SMBH). These black holes are believed to play an essential role in the growth and evolution of galaxies. Studies have shown that there seems to be an apparent relationship between the properties of the central black hole and the large-scale properties of the galaxy, such as its size and mass. This relationship can possibly be established through outflows of gas powered by the central Active Galactic Nuclei (AGN), which can move across the entire galaxy. These outflows can transport mass and energy across the galaxy and thus likely affect the properties of the galaxy at considerable distances from the center.

AGN-powered outflows can occur over long timescales (about a hundred million years). They can move from the central regions to the edge and beyond of the galaxy (distances equivalent to traveling around the Earth about 10 billion times!). These numbers are most certainly beyond the scale of humans, making it difficult to understand the true nature of the effect of outflows on their host galaxies. So, we turn to simulations to help understand this. By injecting the physics of AGN-driven outflows in galaxy simulations, one can speed up timescales and better understand how outflows interact with the interstellar medium (ISM) of the galaxy.

Build a galaxy on your computer!

Today’s authors use a series of controlled numerical simulations to investigate how the ISM affects the propagation of AGN-driven outflows. They have an idealized gas disk with an AGN at the center, powering spherical outflows. The gas disk is set to mimic the ISM of galaxies and can be varied between a smooth and clumpy ISM (Figure 1). The clumpy ISM is made up of clumps of gas clouds of varying sizes and is likely to be similar to the true nature of the ISM. The authors aim to study how the outflow interacts with the ISM, characterize the nature and structure of the outflows, and determine several outflow properties. These include how much mass is carried by the outflow and the rates at which the outflow carries mass, momentum, and kinetic energy. 

Figure 1: The simulation’s ISM setup comprises gas clouds of various sizes (clumps). The distance between the clumps is indicated by the λmax on the top. A schematic of the AGN wind launched by the simulation is shown on the left. Credit: Figure 1 of today’s paper.

The authors determine that the clumpy ISM causes the outflow to have a multiphase nature, a hot phase (with a temperature greater than 106 K) caused by the wind moving through gaps in the disk, and a cool phase caused by the clouds (or clumps) in the medium. The hot phase of the outflow moves faster, with velocities greater than 1000s km/s, while the cold phase moves with the typical velocity of 100 km/s. The cold phase of the outflow carries more mass with it than the hot phase, indicating that the cold phase is likely more efficient in moving mass around in the galaxy. Both phases carry around the same amount of momentum, while the hot phase of the outflow carries more energy than the cold phase. Assuming a smooth ISM also produces outflows with hot and cool phases, but both tend to have similar velocities. Here, the cooler phase of the outflow carries more energy and momentum.

Figure 2: The top left panel indicates the various properties observed and the bi-conical shape of the outflow in a clumpy ISM. The difference in speeds between the central cool region and the dispersed hot region can be observed in the radial velocity panel. The top right panel shows a zoomed-in version of the central region. Here, you can see the two-phase nature of the outflow, with the hot phase in orange and the cool phase in purple. The bottom left panel shows how the cool gas carries more mass (indicated by the increased column density in yellow-green on the right). The bottom right panel shows a zoomed-in version of the larger-scale distribution of cool and hot phases. Credit: Figure 2 of today’s paper.

Combining predictions with observations!

These results also have significance in determining what possible challenges one may encounter as they interpret observations of AGN feedback. For example, they find that the outflows do not necessarily have a spherical shape (see Figure 2, top left panel), as assumed by most observational studies. This may lead to incorrect predictions about the strength of the outflow and how much energy and mass it can carry. Future observations of AGN feedback can help confirm these predictions and provide better constraints on feedback physics to help improve predictions from similar numerical simulations.

Astrobite edited by Karthik Yadavalli

Featured image credit: NASA, ESA, Joseph Olmsted (STScI)

About Archana Aravindan

I am a Ph.D. candidate at the University of California, Riverside, where I study black hole activity in small galaxies. When I am not looking through some incredible telescopes, you can usually find me reading, thinking about policy, or learning a cool language!

Discover more from astrobites

Subscribe to get the latest posts to your email.

Leave a Reply

Discover more from astrobites

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading