Daily paper summaries

Debris Disks and Stars Spin Together

The Solar System is flat. The orbits of the eight planets fall, approximately, in the same plane, and this plane is aligned with the equator of the Sun. While some asteroids and Kuiper belt objects have high inclinations, most of the bodies in these belts are orbiting in this plane, as well. It makes sense that the Sun, planets, and smaller bodies all orbit in the same plane, when we consider that they all formed from the same rotating and collapsing cloud of gas and dust.

Therefore, it was so surprising when astronomers discovered that some exoplanets’ orbits are misaligned from their stars’ equator. Measuring this misalignment was only possible for transiting planets where the Rossiter-McLaughlin effect could be measured. This phenomenon is an observable shift in the wavelength of absorption lines in a star’s spectrum as the transiting planet blocks the blue- or red-shifted parts of the spinning star; it is illustrated nicely in this astrobite.

What causes this spin-orbit misalignment? Four common theories:
a) Perhaps these planets had close encounters with other planets in their system, causing a scattering interaction that drastically tilted their orbits.
b) The Kozai mechanism, where the gravitational influence of a larger planet causes an inner planet’s inclination to oscillate periodically, thereby making the inner planet misaligned with the star’s equator at times.
c) Some astronomers think that the star, when it is young, can tip over because of interactions between its magnetic field and its protoplanetary disk.
d) Maybe the protoplanetary disk became tilted when a neighboring star and disk passed close by.

Figure 1. An image at 70 microns of the HD 115617 debris disk taken by Herschel. The shape of the disks in these images were used to determine the disks' inclination, assuming they are intrinsically circular.

Figure 1. An image at far-infrared wavelengths of the HD 115617 debris disk taken by Herschel. The shape of the disk in this image is used to determine the disk’s inclination, assuming it is intrinsically circular.

To narrow down the possibilities, we’d like to know if the misalignment is only present for close-in transiting planets or if the outer regions of planetary systems can also be misaligned. But finding far-out planets–and measuring the inclinations of their orbits–is difficult. Debris disks, however, are much easier to detect. And, by spatially resolving debris disks, we can not only determine their true shapes and sizes, but also their inclinations.

The authors of this paper study 11 debris disks that were resolved by the Herschel Space Observatory in the far-infrared, and whose stars also have well-measured spin orientations. Figure 1 shows an example Herschel image of a debris disk. By assuming the disk is truly circular, the shape of the image reveals the inclination angle at which we are viewing it.

The inclination of a star’s spin axis is found in two steps. First, the broadening of the star’s spectral lines caused by its rotation is measured. This yields v*sin(i), where v is the rotational velocity of the star’s equator, and i is the inclination. Second, v is independently estimated using the star’s size and its period of rotation (found by monitoring its brightness oscillations). Combing these measurements gives i, the star’s inclination.

For these eleven stars, the authors find that the plane of the disks are aligned with the equators of the stars to within 10 degrees. Their results are illustrated in Figure 2, which plots the disk inclination (from our viewpoint) on the x axis and a measure of the star-disk alignment on the y axis. This suggests that the previously-observed spin-orbit misalignments are not caused by the star or the entire planetary system tilting, but by a mechanism that specifically affects the orbits of close-in planets. Planet-planet scattering or Kozai oscillations now seem more likely, whereas magnetic interactions between the star and protoplanetary disk or encounters with nearby stars are less plausible. More research will be necessary to figure out exactly how some close-in planets’ orbits become misaligned.

Figure 2. The disk-star alignment (y-axis) versus the disk inclination (x-axis) for the eleven stars considered in this paper (plus the Sun). The y axis is the Pythagorean trigonometric identity, expressed with the star and disk inclination angles, which would equal 1 if the angles are the same.

Figure 2. The disk-star alignment (y-axis) versus the disk inclination (x-axis) for the eleven stars considered in this paper (plus the Sun). The y axis is the Pythagorean trigonometric identity expressed with the star and disk inclination angles, which would equal 1 if the angles are the same.

Download this article as an e-book (epub or mobi format)

The following two tabs change content below.

Nick Ballering

I am a graduate student in astronomy at the University of Arizona. My research interests include debris disks, planet formation, exoplanet detection and characterization, and astrobiology. Currently, I am working with George Rieke to study the structure and evolution of planetary systems using observations of debris disks. I graduated from the University of Wisconsin in 2008 — go Badgers!

Latest posts by Nick Ballering (see all)


4 Responses to “Debris Disks and Stars Spin Together”

  1. So how does Kepler-56 fit in? :)

    Posted by Johanna | November 4, 2013, 10:51 pm
    • Just googling gave a ref:

      “Follow-up radial velocity measurements revealed the evidence of a gravitational perturbator but currently it is not clear if it is a nearby star or a third planet.[1]”

      [1. ^ [Huber et al.] (2013-10-21). “Stellar Spin-Orbit Misalignment in a Multiplanet System” (HTML) (in English). Cornell University Library. ]

      Posted by Torbjörn Larsson, OM | November 10, 2013, 9:59 am
    • Today’s astrobite (Nov 12, 2013) addresses this very paper about Kepler-56! It’s not clear why Kepler-56 is misaligned, and as this post demonstrates, alignment (or not) of planetary systems is an ongoing area of research.

      Posted by Meredith Rawls | November 12, 2013, 3:02 pm
  2. From here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kepler-56

    Another misedit:

    “Asteroseismological studies revealed that the orbits of Kepler-56b and Kepler-56c are about 45° misaligned to the host star’s equator. Follow-up radial velocity …”

    Posted by Torbjörn Larsson, OM | November 10, 2013, 10:02 am

Leave a Reply

Want an Astrobites t-shirt?

Enter the Astrobites reader survey to help us focus our content and style to serve you best. You could win a free Astrobites t-shirt!

Follow us on Twitter

Like us on Facebook


    http://astrobites.tumblr.com/post/65549158012http://astrobites.tumblr.com/post/62345439779http://astrobites.tumblr.com/post/60939853775http://astrobites.tumblr.com/post/59050954779Visit Astroplots to explore astronomy research through data representation.


Enter your email address to subscribe to Astrobites and receive notifications of new posts by email.