Zapping PAHs? Yee-haw!

Title: Dissociation and destruction of PAHs and PAH clusters induced by absorption of X-rays in protoplanetary discs around T Tauri stars

Authors: K. Lange, C. Dominik, A.G.G.M. Tielens

First author’s institution: Anton Pannekoek Institute for Astronomy, University of Amsterdam, Science-Park 904, 1098 XH Amsterdam, Netherlands

Status: Accepted to Astronomy & Astrophysics [open access]

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are honeycomb-shaped carbonaceous molecules that contain something like 10-25% of all carbon in the universe. PAHs make up some of the smallest dust grains in the interstellar medium (ISM) and act to dim the light from background objects, a process known as extinction. We know a lot about PAHs from laboratory experiments and observational astronomy because of the vibrational bending and stretching modes of C-C and C-H bonds that produce prominent emission features in the infrared. 

This figure shows the cascade by which PAHs are destroyed, first being removed from the surface of dust grains, second being dissociated from large clusters, and third being broken down by successively losing acetylenes.
Figure 1: The cascading process by which PAHs break down, from desorption from a dust grain to the dissociation of a large cluster to individual PAHs, which can break down into smaller carbonaceous molecules. Figure 2 from today’s paper.

PAHs are thus easily observable. However, PAHs seem to be surprisingly absent from planet-forming disks around young T Tauri stars. These are highly variable, young stars that have not yet ignited fusion. Since these systems are so young, they still have protoplanetary disks made of gas and dust leftover from star formation. T Tauri stars also have strong magnetic fields and are thus strong emitters of X-rays. Today’s authors ask whether the X-ray luminosity from these young stars is sufficient to destroy PAHs. The abundance of PAHs is expected to greatly affect the photochemistry of these disks, and consequently planet formation, since PAHs are strong absorbers of high-energy UV and X-ray photons, which T Tauri stars emit abundantly.

This figure shows that the fraction of PAHs destroyed in the gas phase does not change with PAH size and is largely dependent on excitation energy.
Figure 2: Fraction of PAHs destroyed in the gas-phase for four PAH species after absorbing an X-ray photon. Figure 4 from today’s paper.

To start, the authors of today’s paper must model the microphysics of X-ray + PAH interactions. First, PAHs can exist in large clusters or as monomers, and on the surface of dust grains or in the gas-phase. A PAH is most stable if it starts as a large cluster on a dust grain, since three steps are required to fully destroy it, as shown in Figure 1: desorption, cluster dissociation and PAH dissociation. A PAH is most fragile if it starts as a monomer in the gas-phase so let’s start with this case. An X-ray hitting a PAH will cause ionization and vibrational excitation. The PAH can lose this extra energy in two ways: non-dissociatively (by emitting photons) or dissociatively (by breaking apart). We care about the dissociative pathway that results in a PAH losing an acetylene (C2H2) and thus breaking up into smaller pieces. Figure 2 shows the probability of PAH destruction for four PAH species as a function of excitation energy, which is shown to be largely independent of the particular PAH species.

This figure shows that large PAHs in large clusters are very difficult to remove from those clusters.
Figure 3: Fraction of destroyed PAH clusters in the gas-phase. Light to dark colors indicate higher energy excitations, and PAH sizes increase from left to right. Larger clusters and larger PAHs are more resistant to dissociation. Figure 5 from today’s paper.

The authors also investigate the other steps of PAH destruction: cluster dissociation and desorption, which is relevant for PAHs in clusters and/or adsorbed on dust grains. Figure 3 shows the fraction of ejected PAH monomers as a function of cluster size and excitation energy. Figure 4 shows the desorption probability as a function of dust grain temperature, excitation energy, and cluster size for four PAH species. In both cases, we see that it is very difficult to destroy large PAH species and large clusters.

This figure shows that large PAHs in large clusters are very difficult to remove from the surface of dust grains.
Figure 4: Desorption probability as a function of grain temperature (gray lines have T = 200 K, colored lines have T = 400 K), excitation energy (light lines have E = 15 eV, medium E = 25 eV, dark E = 35 eV), PAH size (which increases left to right), and cluster size. The PAH size greatly influences desorption, making large PAHs very difficult to detach from dust grains. Figure 6 from today’s paper.
This figure shows that the gas-phase abundance of PAHs in T Tauri disks is depleted by orders of magnitude relative to the ISM level over time.
Figure 5: Abundance of PAHs in various states relative to the background ISM abundance. Over time, X-rays are able to substantially reduce the gas-phase PAH abundance in T Tauri disks. Figure 8 from today’s paper.

X-rays are clearly capable of influencing PAHs, especially by breaking down smaller PAH monomers and clusters. However, it is more difficult to dissociate large PAH clusters, especially those adsorbed onto dust grains. Figure 5 summarizes the results, showing a substantial reduction in gas-phase PAH abundance over time, largely driven by the destruction of smaller PAH monomers and clusters. Observations of T Tauri disks by JWST could greatly expand our understanding of these systems and whether PAHs are present. Our very own Solar System is thought to have formed out of a T Tauri disk in the past, so studying these systems will elucidate how planets like ours form.

Astrobite edited by Skylar Grayson and Joe Williams

Featured Image Credit: NASA/JPL-Caltech/T. Pyle (SSC)

Author

  • Kylee Carden

    I am a PhD student at Johns Hopkins University, where I am an observer of planets outside the Solar System. I’m interested in dynamics, disks, demographics, the Roman Space Telescope. I am a huge fan of my cat Piccadilly, cycling, and visiting underappreciated tourist sites.

    View all posts

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *