A New Kind of Radio Lighthouse

Title: Sporadic radio pulses from a white dwarf binary at the orbital period

Author(s): I. de Ruiter, K. M. Rajwade, C. G. Bassa, A. Rowlinson, R. A. M. J. Wijers, C. D. Kilpatrick, G. Stefansson, J. R. Callingham, J. W. T. Hessels, T. E. Clarke, W. Peters, R. A. D. Wijnands, T. W. Shimwell, S. ter Veen, V. Morello, G. R. Zeimann & S. Mahadevan

First Author’s Institution: Sydney Institute for Astronomy, School of Physics, The University of Sydney, Sydney, New South Wales, Australia

Status: Published in Nature Astronomy [open access]

A brief history of radio pulsators

Periodic radio sources have been studied for several decades, beginning with the discovery of the pulsar by Jocelyn Bell Burnell as a graduate student in 1968. Pulsars are made up of highly magnetized (up to a quadrillion times the magnetic field of the Earth) neutron stars, the remnants of massive stars left behind after their energetic death in a supernova. Pulsars are among the most precise clocks in the universe. In 2006, sporadic, unusual pulses from neutron stars were identified and dubbed Rotating Radio Transients (RRATs) for their distinctive, unpredictable behavior. Shortly thereafter, in 2007, Fast Radio Bursts (FRBs) were identified, but only a small fraction of FRBs are known “repeaters” (see this live catalog of repeaters from the CHIME collaboration). The origin of FRBs remains debated, although promising observations of FRBs in our own galaxy suggest that one origin is magnetars. Still, it’s possible that the objects that generate FRBs aren’t all the same. 

Since FRB signals arrive randomly and telescope time is at a premium, it is challenging to search for candidates for this phenomenon. Most discoveries of FRBs are serendipitous; we were lucky to be observing the right part of the sky with the right telescope at the time of the FRB pulse’s arrival. However, the global radio astronomy community recognizes the importance of sensitive, all-sky coverage, leading to increased efforts to produce surveys that observe the same regions of the sky multiple times. An example of this is the LOFAR Two-Metre Sky Survey (LoTSS), which utilizes the Low Frequency Array (LOFAR) in the Netherlands. Today’s authors use the LoTSS to observe at 120-168 MHz (just above FM radio, spanning 88-108 MHz) and identify a new kind of repeating radio source. 

Rotation or orbits?

The top panel shows two pulses: the first begins at roughly 22 seconds, with a flux density of about 0.22 Jy/beam, and lasts for 10 seconds. A second pulse, shorter and brighter at 0.35 Jy/beam, begins at 36 seconds and lasts for 8 seconds. The bottom panel displays a similar result, but with different amplitudes spanning the frequency range, with the brightest pulse at the lowest frequency, reaching nearly 0.4 Jy/beam.
Figure 1: The top panel displays the light curve of the brightest pulse, and the bottom panel shows the same pulse’s “dynamic spectrum,” where the x-axis is time, the y-axis is frequency, and the color represents the brightness at that time and frequency. A dynamic spectrum is interpreted as follows: each vertical column represents a single spectrum at a specific time, and the following times progress from left to right.

By searching for rapidly changing sources in the LoTSS survey, today’s authors were able to identify a single bright radio pulse from an object named ILT J110160.52 + 552119.62 (ILT J1101 + 5521 for short). Once identified, the authors searched other archival observations collected with LOFAR and found six additional pulses, lasting between 30 seconds and 90 seconds. The pulses were actually periodic, occurring at the same time in a 125.52978-minute period (+/-1.2 millisecond uncertainty). Additional inspection of the brightest pulse revealed a very intriguing double-peaked structure in its light curve and a strong dependence on the observed frequency, with higher frequencies significantly dimmer; see Figure 1. Such a long period is atypical of a traditional radio pulsator source, which are usually much faster (e.g., pulsars, which can rotate with periods as short as milliseconds).

Observations of the radial velocity value inferred from six MMT Binospec observations and one HET LRS2-R observation are shown overplotted on the best-fitting sinusoidal radial velocity solution. The predicted radio flare is marked in time by a vertical line, indicating that the secondary M dwarf's switch from positive to negative RV (inferior conjunction) is the emission time of the radio pulse.
Figure 2: By observing the source with optical wavelengths, today’s authors were able to measure shifts in the emission/absorption lines of the spectrum relative to the rest wavelength, a technique known as the radial velocity method (RV or Doppler spectroscopy), which is commonly utilized to observe stars’ reflex motion due to the orbit of another body around them.

To determine the origin of this unique radio signal, today’s authors searched archival observations spanning the near-ultraviolet through the optical spectrum and beyond to the near-infrared. They found a candidate optical source with a roughly 1 in 10,000 chance of not originating from the same coordinates as the radio pulse, indicating that they are very likely to originate from the same star system. By modeling the source’s luminosity across this wavelength range, they were able to suggest that this source is a combination of an M dwarf (a low-mass star) and a white dwarf. By following up on the source with additional spectroscopy observed over multiple, closely spaced times (see Figure 2), they observed radial velocity variations with the same period as the radio pulsations. The RV measurement revealed periodic variations in the line profile centroids at the same period as the radio pulsation, allowing today’s authors to infer that the periodic effect is one due to an orbit, rather than the rotation of a single body, like in the pulsar scenario.

Prospects

This system is remarkably similar to a known class of binary objects called “polars,” consisting of an old M dwarf and a magnetized WD that are in a close orbit, sometimes as short as 90 minutes. Polars are known to be occasional radio emitters but remain understudied in detail. Today’s authors identified a very similar system, suggesting that more of this type could be found and that other polars may display similar radio behavior.  Follow-up of known polar systems at different wavelengths to search for correlations between the radio pulse and the system’s orbit would allow further comparison with systems like ILT J1101 + 5521 to understand better the mechanism of the periodic radio emission and its origin in the binary.

Edited by Erica Sawczynec

Author

  • Will Golay

    I am a graduate student in the Department of Astronomy at Harvard University and the Center for Astrophysics | Harvard & Smithsonian, advised by Edo Berger. I study radio emission from transient astrophysical objects like tidal disruption events.

    View all posts

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *