- Title: A Pilot Search for Evidence of Extrasolar Earth-analog Plate Tectonics
- Authors: M. Jura, B. Klein, S. Xu, and E. D. Young
- First Author’s Institution: Department of Physics and Astronomy, University of California, Los Angeles
- Paper’s Status: Accepted to The Astrophysical Journal Letters
Plate tectonics is a unique feature of Earth. Unlike every other rocky body in our Solar System, Earth’s crust is broken up into roughly a dozen pieces (plates) that move around with different velocities. When two plates converge, one plate sinks under the other in a process called subduction, eventually becoming recycled into the mantle and causing volcanism, earthquakes, and mountain building on the surface.
Plate tectonics regulates Earth’s atmospheric composition through the cycle of subduction and volcanic degassing. Subduction returns carbonate rocks like limestone from the seafloor into the mantle, for example, while carbon dioxide is emitted from volcanoes at plate boundaries. It’s probably not a coincidence that the only known planet with plate tectonics is the only one with life. So, we’d really like to know if plate tectonics is a thing that happens on terrestrial exoplanets.
Today’s paper discusses the first step in a search for evidence of plate tectonics—a hunt for the remnants of continental crust within two white dwarfs that have accreted little bits of rocky planets, aka planetesimals. Although these two stars yielded no evidence for extrasolar plate tectonics, a survey of more targets seems exceedingly worthwhile.
Telltale Signs of Plate Tectonics
To a rough approximation, rocky planets are chemically differentiated into three distinct layers. Early in the process of planetary formation, an iron-rich core separates from a silicate mantle. A basaltic crust then forms over time from the partial melting of the mantle. Oxygen and silicon are the most abundant elements in basaltic crust, followed by calcium and aluminum, as observed on Mars, the Moon, and Vesta.
Earth’s oceanic crust is basaltic, but we also have continental crust, which forms from partial melting of subducted oceanic crust. Continental crust is chemically distinct because it is extremely enriched in “incompatible” elements that generally have large ionic radii and thus tend to come out of a partially melting rock. In particular, Earth’s continental crust is dramatically enriched in strontium and barium, by factors of ~10-100 relative to calcium. No other known process can produce similarly high elemental ratios.
Continents are less dense than oceanic crust, so they tend to stick around on the surface, as shown on Figure 1. If a planet has plate tectonics for a significant part of its history, then evidence should remain on its outermost skin. Unfortunately, we can’t send a probe to any exoplanets in the foreseeable future, nor can we spectrally analyze the surfaces of distant rocky planets from Earth. Using a new technique, however, we can search the corpses of Sun-like stars for remnants of Earth-like planets.
A Pilot Search of Two White Dwarfs
Our Sun will end its life as a white dwarf, after it expands into a red giant and sheds its outer layers as planetary nebulae. (N.b., planetary nebulae have nothing to do with planets and are a great example of astronomers being very silly with words. But they look cool!) Planets could survive this end stage of stellar evolution and remain orbiting the white dwarf.
Elements heavier than hydrogen or helium quickly (in ~10,000 years) sink below the observable photosphere of white dwarfs. This is fascinating, because observing heavier elements in the spectrum of a white dwarf means that something like a rocky planetesimal has just accreted, or is accreting, onto the “polluted” white dwarf. (Without external accretion, we expect to see only hydrogen and helium.) Scientists used these tactics to argue for extremely water-rich asteroids orbiting the white dwarf GD 61.
Imagine the following scenario: an asteroid impact knocks off part of the crust from a planet orbiting a white dwarf that has plate tectonics. If these crustal remnants were then accreted onto the white dwarf, then we could observe signs of rocky material with a very high barium-to-calcium or strontium-to-calcium ratio in its spectrum.
Figure 2 shows the region of the spectrum of the polluted white dwarf GD 362 (black data) that would reveal an absorption line of barium. Alack, the authors place an upper limit on the barium abundance (red model) that excludes the accretion of a significant amount of continental crust. Similar results were obtained for another polluted white dwarf, PG 1225-079.
Current observational techniques are sufficient to detect signs of continental crust, if nature were to obligingly provide. Accretion of continental crust onto a white dwarf is probably an exceedingly rare event, even if rocky planets with plate tectonics are plentiful. But finding a plate tectonics is a big step towards finding life, so the search continues.